Success. Well I finally go everything set up as I had originally hoped. I ended up just going to Radio Shack and getting a 4 way A/V switch. It is suiting my purposes nicely. I was going to return the Tivo and get a combo unit but at this point it would have been a hassle. I'm very happy.

Thank you all for your thoughts and suggestions. I can see how the Tivo has changed a lot of peoples' TV viewing habits.